Ah, childhood in America. Baseball. Hot dogs. Apple pie. Group vows advocating liberty and justice for all. I have vivid memories of our class rising to its collective feet and repeating the 15-second Pledge of Allegiance toward the flag above the chalkboard. In theory, you could opt out, but I dare you to try that with Mrs. Murray already trying to determine who threw that paper airplane.
The modern American pledge had been around since the 1890s, gaining official status during World War II when patriotism was at an all-time high. Although that 1942 act of Congress never mandated the pledge, most states passed their own laws requiring students to recite it regularly. It might sound like brainwashing, but this kind of thing works in America because that nation is an “affidavit society,” something I talked about a few weeks back. In such an environment, every person has the authority to make legally binding statements about themselves. I’m sure that most junior high students chant the text with no feeling at all. But for those who believe it, their declaration is valid.
No Japanese Pledge on the Horizon
Japan has no parallel pledge. Given the uniformity of its society, you would think that Japan of all places would have a communal statement regarding obligation and devotion to the nation. It does have the shared language of the Kimigayo, the national anthem. But the text of that hymn is more of an encouraging statement on the longevity of the country (or its emperor, depending on who you ask), not an oath of obedience.
America may have codified its pledge during a burst of national zeal, but I don’t see Japan doing the same thing, even if there was a sudden need for such public unity. Part of this conjecture stems from the country’s prewar educational framework. The 1890 Imperial Rescript on Education declared that in times of national emergency, the citizenry, including students, should “offer yourselves courageously to the State and thus guard and maintain the prosperity of the Imperial Throne.” Some historians link this act to Japan’s fervor in the run-up to World War II. Yet this was a directive from on high, and not a verbal incantation that children had to emote each day. As a nation that now officially rejects the “use of force as means of settling international disputes” (from Article 9 of Japan’s constitution), it is unlikely to burden schoolchildren with mouthing a constant reminder of civil duty.
Just Ask the Boss
Even if you ignore pedagogical practices from a century ago, Japan nonetheless doesn’t impose a standard pledge because it doesn’t need to. As a “guarantor society,” individuals are able to defer such assurances to someone higher up in the social hierarchy. Back in the Meiji Era, that someone was the emperor himself. At the promulgation of the country’s 1889 constitution, Emperor Meiji did “humbly and solemnly swear to the Imperial Founder of Our House and to Our other Imperial Ancestors that…We shall maintain and secure from decline the ancient form of government.” In essence, he took the pledge upon himself as an example and placeholder for all citizens, since he was authorized to do so by divine right. Allegiance of all citizens was bundled in automatically.
Today, the role of guarantor is played by the constitution itself, the supreme law of the land, in which the sovereign people pledge their “national honor to accomplish these high ideals and purposes with all [their] resources.” That one-time statement is sufficient to bind the citizenry to the preservation of the country. Even when someone becomes a naturalized citizen of Japan, their oath is mostly limited to upholding this core document and its societal goals: “I swear to obey the Constitution of Japan as well as its laws and ordinances, fulfilling the established duties, and become a good citizen.”
Allegiance is the Default
The closest thing Japan has to a pledge of allegiance is perhaps the Law Regarding the National Flag and National Anthem, a 1999 act that codified the standards for Japan’s national song and banner. As far as laws go, it’s not that exciting, defining such things as the precise ratio between the flag’s width and height. A recent update to the law made it a crime to desecrate the flag. But even in this case, the law makes no regular demands for assent on either schoolchildren or adults.
In other words, when Japanese go about their day as ordinary citizens, they are already meeting the standard. It makes a daily vocal promise of allegiance redundant, since the way citizens live their lives and the expectations for allegiance look nearly identical.
Image Credits: 旅するししゃも/photo-ac